Sunday, December 11 – 5:00pm
I wasn’t able to make it to our Holiday Year in Review event this year, but we had another event in December, where we used the 2019 edition of Joy of Cooking. This massive cookbook has thousands of Irma Rombauer’s classic American recipes, plus over 600 new recipes from Irma’s great-grandson, John Becker, and his wife, Megan Scott.
As we all know, Joy of Cooking is Anthony’s favorite cookbook, and he has a well-loved copy that he uses all the time. For the holidays he was gifted the 2019 edition, so he hosted this event to focus specifically on that newer version of the cookbook. We ate every dish as its own course, which is a great way to savor each recipe individually as well as to have a nice long meal to socialize!
The Menu
I made Mushroom-Scallion Soup. I will definitely be making this again. Like a cream of mushroom soup, but even better because it had a lot of green onions blended in as well as sprinkled on top. Naran doesn’t normally like mushroom soup, and even he liked it!
Anthony made Kimchi Mac and Cheese. The cookbook called for 1 cup of kimchi mixed into the Macaroni and Cheese recipe. Anthony didn’t realize until too late that he only had about 1/3 cup of kimchi, but even with that small amount it added a nice depth of flavor. I want to try it with a full cup of kimchi.
Robert made Kreplach – Jewish dumplings served in hearty broth. The recipe suggested using minced chicken or ground beef for the filling, but Robert used ground lamb which was a very tasty choice. Like a Jewish version of one of my faves – wonton soup!
Kamy made Green Beans. Searching through the thousands of recipes and not finding this one? That’s because it’s not there. Kamy got confused and thought we were using The Silver Spoon. In her defense, I can see how she might mix up her classic cookbook tomes haha.
Anthony also made Hungarian Goulash. He served it over your choice of boiled potatoes or rice. The dollop of sour cream was optional according to the recipe, but essential in my opinion – it added just the right amount of acidity and gave the dish a perfect creaminess.
Naran made Coq Au Vin (Chicken Braised in Wine). I will never forget the first time I ate Coq Au Vin. Perhaps time has amplified this dish in my mind, because this one was tasty but just didn’t compare to the rich flavors of my memory.
Anthony also made Spiced Pumpkin Ice Cream. He served it with gingerbread (not from the cookbook). I am getting burnt out on pumpkin-spice everything these days, but I always enjoy the ice creams Anthony makes and this was no exception.
Eileen made The Rombauer Special Chocolate Cake. She felt it was a little dry and would have given it a bit less cooking time. It’s light on chocolate, while I prefer my cake more chocolate-y. The frosting is marshmallow-like, which also isn’t my favorite, but it has its appeal for some as it was Irma Rombauer’s go-to for family birthdays.
The Verdict
When we used Joy of Cooking for Cookbook Club before, I found it to be somewhat overwhelming, and not surprisingly with such a huge selection the recipes were a mixed bag ranging from blah to YUM. This time the dishes we tried brought more joy than not, but there were still highs and lows and the book itself still daunts.
Want in? Join the Cookbook Club mailing list to be notified when new posts go live.