Milk Street: Tuesday Nights – Christopher Kimball
Sunday, March 1 – 6:00pm

Our February cookbook was Milk Street: Tuesday Nights by Christopher Kimball. Winner of the James Beard Award for best general cookbook, every recipe is meant to be quick and easy enough for cooking in the middle of the week. Some dishes are categorized into Fast (under an hour), Faster (45 minutes or less), or Fastest (25 minutes or less), and others fall into themes like Supper Salads or Easy Additions.

Milk Street: Tuesday Nights spread

Anthony did a great job hosting as always, even with a last-minute swap to indoors since the weather was too cold for us California wimps. We all sat at two tables in close enough proximity to be able to converse across both. Little did we know that it might be our last opportunity to gather together and share a meal for quite some time, as shortly thereafter COVID-19 was declared a global pandemic. We hope that everyone is staying healthy and safe at home, and if something positive can come out of this coronavirus outbreak it’s that more people are home cooking!

Milk Street: Tuesday Nights party

The Menu

Creamy Fennel and Bean Soup - Brad

Creamy Fennel and Bean Soup – Brad

Brad made Creamy Fennel and Bean Soup. The broth was super flavorful, and it was nice to have some beans not blended for a little texture. With the bacon and chives sprinkled on top adding a bit of crunch, smokiness, and bite, this was a wonderful soup that I’d be happy to have again.

Herbed Egg Salad with Pickled Red Onion - JeeYun

Herbed Egg Salad with Pickled Red Onion – JeeYun

JeeYun made Herbed Egg Salad with Pickled Red Onion. She served it with nice seedy crackers, and this was a wonderful treat that everyone kept going back for more of… even people who said they don’t normally like egg salad! Maybe because it used a vinegar and yolk mixture instead of mayonnaise.

Indonesian Fried Tofu Salad - Erin

Indonesian Fried Tofu Salad – Erin

Erin made Indonesian Fried Tofu Salad. With pineapple and grapes as main ingredients, this was seemingly a fruit salad, only I’ve never had a fruit salad with fried tofu before. On my first bite I wasn’t sure what to make of this salad, but with each successive bite it sort of grew on me.

Bread Salad with Kale, Beets, and Blue Cheese - Drew

Bread Salad with Kale, Beets, and Blue Cheese – Drew

Drew made Bread Salad with Kale, Beets and Blue Cheese. It was delicious. The kale was tender, the fried bread added nice crunch and body, beets and honey gave it sweetness, and the creaminess of the blue cheese rounded it all out perfectly.

Stir-Fried Broccoli with Sichuan Peppercorns - Shayna

Stir-Fried Broccoli with Sichuan Peppercorns – Shayna

Shayna made Stir-Fried Broccoli with Sichuan Peppercorns. She thought it was boring, but I liked it, perhaps because it reminded my of the broccoli my mom made all the time when I was growing up. Other people also really enjoyed the typical Asian garlic-ginger-soy-spice combo that’s hard to go wrong with.

Sweet-and-Spicy Ginger Green Beans - Brian

Sweet-and-Spicy Ginger Green Beans – Brian

Brian made Sweet-and-Spicy Ginger Green Beans. Also very reminiscent of green beans I’ve been eating for much of my life, I was happy to eat these. The combination of sugar, soy, fish sauce, ginger, vinegar, white pepper, and red pepper flakes is again commonly used in Asian cuisine, and for good reason.

Pasta all’Amatriciana - Alana

Pasta all’Amatriciana – Alana

I made Pasta all’Amatriciana. The flavors were great from white wine and a lot of garlic, a bit of spice thanks to red pepper flakes and black pepper, and crisp salty bits of pancetta. My only complaint is that the pasta was a bit overcooked – next time I’d boil it for less time to keep it more al dente.

Three-Cheese Pizza - Anthony

Three-Cheese Pizza – Anthony

Anthony made Three-Cheese Pizza. In highly precise Anthony style, he weighed out exactly the specified amounts of mozzarella, fontina, and parmesan cheeses. It was tasty, but I would have been happy with more cheese.

Vietnamese Meatball Lettuce Wraps - Anthony

Vietnamese Meatball Lettuce Wraps – Anthony

Anthony also made Vietnamese Meatball Lettuce Wraps. These were fantastic. The meatballs were tasty on their own, and when wrapped in the lettuce leaves and topped with seasoned carrots, cilantro, scallions, and the lime/sugar/chili/fish sauce were a treat I couldn’t get enough of.

Za’atar-Roasted Chicken - Barbara

Za’atar-Roasted Chicken – Barbara

Barbara made Za’atar-Roasted Chicken. I am a big fan of za’atar, and this dish goes big with it, giving the chicken a healthy coating that fully embraces the seasoning. It was really good topped with the garlicky lemon sauce.

Georgian Chicken with Walnut-Cilantro Sauce - Hector

Georgian Chicken with Walnut-Cilantro Sauce – Hector

Hector made Georgian Chicken with Walnut-Cilantro Sauce. This dish managed to have tons of wonderfully rich sauce surrounding tender chicken that still had crisp to its skin. I wouldn’t have been able to guess all the ingredients that made up the sauce – all I could tell you was it tasted incredible.

White Balsamic Chicken with Tarragon - Tammy

White Balsamic Chicken with Tarragon – Tammy

Tammy made White Balsamic Chicken with Tarragon. I’ve been hearing a lot about vinegar chicken lately, so I was excited to try this one. Disappointingly, I found it a bit uninteresting, but it may just have suffered in comparison to the very bold flavors of the other two chicken dishes.

Coconut-Saffron Macaroons - Erin

Coconut-Saffron Macaroons – Erin

Erin also made Coconut-Saffron Macaroons. I love saffron, cardamom, and ginger, so I thought I would adore these cookies, but I found them somehow off-putting. The saffron gave them an appealing aesthetic, but for some reason those spice flavors didn’t work for me in a macaroon.

Brazilian Chocolate Fudge - Heather

Brazilian Chocolate Fudge – Heather

Heather made Brazilian Chocolate Fudge. She felt it was too heavy on the cinnamon, so she added some sea salt to the cashew coating, which was a really nice complement to the rich fudge. I thought these were good, and with a little less cinnamon to allow the espresso and cocoa flavors to come through, they would be amazing.

Benne Seed Cookies - Hector

Benne Seed Cookies – Hector

Hector also made Benne Seed Cookies. With white sesame seeds, black sesame seeds, and tahini, these were sesame on sesame on sesame… and that’s all right with me. If you like sesame, you’ll love the intense toasty nuttiness of these cookies.

The Verdict

The moment I opened Milk Street: Tuesday Nights, I fell in love with it. Every recipe had a full-page gorgeous picture. There were an abundance of approachably short ingredient lists. So many dishes sounded appealing to me that I had a hard time choosing which one I was going to make. I was so enamored of this cookbook that I was a little bit afraid the meal couldn’t possibly live up to my expectations. But it did. The food was terrific, and indeed simple enough that I have a long list of recipes I’m looking forward to trying on many upcoming Tuesday nights.

Want in? Join the Cookbook Club mailing list to be notified when new posts go live.